The Coin That Always Lands on Its Edge: Supernatural Short Story

riya's blogs
Written by:
Categories:

The night it began, the sky was a pale bruise over the city — purple fading into something unnameable. Ethan didn’t notice the color. He rarely did. He was sitting on the park bench where the old oak tree leaned like a tired sentinel, flicking a coin between his fingers. It wasn’t special, not yet — just a tarnished quarter he’d found at the bottom of a drawer filled with receipts, forgotten notes, and the remains of his former self.

The world had been pressing in on him lately. Every choice he made seemed to collapse into something wrong. He’d taken a new job that felt like a cage. Moved into a high-rise that looked beautiful in listings but echoed with loneliness. Said yes to things he didn’t want, no to things he should’ve loved.

He wasn’t superstitious, but he was tired. And tired people make wishes in strange ways.

He flipped the coin — once, twice — until the habit became a rhythm. A small rebellion against uncertainty. Then, without thinking, he whispered, “Let this decide.”This may contain: a pile of coins sitting on top of a cushion

It wasn’t for anything grand. Just whether to call her.
Her — meaning Clara, the one who had left when he forgot how to listen. The one who said he treated life like a draft version, always saving, never publishing.

He balanced the coin on his thumb, exhaled, and sent it into the night.

It spun, glinting once in the dim park light — and when it fell, it didn’t fall at all.

It landed on its edge.

Perfectly upright, quivering like it had a heartbeat.

Ethan stared. The wind brushed past, leaves rattling, but the coin didn’t topple. It stood there between yes and no, as if mocking the very idea of decision.

He crouched, hesitated to touch it, then laughed softly. “You’ve got to be kidding me.”

But it wasn’t a joke.

Because when he finally did pick it up, something in the air shifted — just slightly, like a whisper through glass.

And then, things began to change.

The first change was small enough to ignore.

On his way home, Ethan crossed the old bridge that divided the city. A woman selling flowers waved him over. He never stopped for street vendors, but this time, something tugged at him.

“White lilies,” she said. “They last longer than you think.”

He didn’t need flowers. He didn’t even like lilies. But he bought them anyway.

When he reached his building, the elevator was out of order — again — so he climbed ten flights of stairs, cursing softly with each step. He didn’t notice that the lilies, despite the heat, stayed fresh for days.

He didn’t notice, either, that his phone buzzed at 3:07 a.m. with a message from Clara.
Not a word, just a photo — a blurry shot of the moon over the same bridge.

He didn’t reply.

The coin rested on his nightstand, half-forgotten, half-watched.

By the end of the week, he realized the pattern.

Every time he made a choice, something — unpredictable — happened.

He said yes to an after-work drink and ended up meeting a stranger who looked eerily like someone from his dreams. He turned left instead of right and avoided a car crash by seconds. He skipped a meeting and somehow got promoted.

Each event felt too right, too perfectly aligned. Coincidences stacked like cards — fragile, deliberate.

And then came the wrongs.

Because the same coin that saved him from one fate seemed to punish him for another.Story Pin image

He ignored a call from his mother — and she fell ill that night. He threw away the lilies — and his apartment filled with a sour smell that wouldn’t fade.

He lost track of what the word “choice” meant.

At night, he’d lie in bed, flipping the coin over his knuckles, whispering to it. “Which side are you on?”

It never answered, but sometimes, he thought he saw it gleam in the dark — faintly, like it understood.

By the third week, reality began to ripple.

It wasn’t dramatic, not at first.

Objects moved slightly when he wasn’t looking. The clocks in his apartment ticked out of rhythm. He’d catch glimpses of himself in mirrors — not reflections, exactly, but versions.

In one, he was smiling. In another, tired.
Once, he saw himself crying.

He tried to explain it away — stress, insomnia, too much caffeine — but deep down, he knew.

The coin had tilted the axis of his life.

He wasn’t deciding anymore. He was being decided for.

The breaking point came on a Thursday.

Ethan was walking home from work when a storm rolled in, heavy and sudden. He ducked under a shop’s awning, shaking rain from his hair, and there — across the street — he saw Clara.

She was holding her umbrella wrong, tilted to the wind, face turned up like she’d been waiting for the rain all day.

For a moment, he thought it was fate. The universe giving him a second chance.

He reached for the coin, heart pounding. “Heads, I go to her. Tails, I don’t.”

He flipped it.

It spun midair, silver against the stormlight — and landed on its edge.

Again.

Perfect. Unmoving.

He froze.

And then, across the street, Clara looked up — straight at him — her expression flickering between recognition and something like fear.

She dropped her umbrella. The light from a passing car caught the water on her face — or were those tears?

When he stepped forward, a horn blared. A truck skidded past, missing her by inches.

By the time he crossed, she was gone.

Only her umbrella remained, spinning slowly in the gutter, as if mocking the spin of his coin.

He pocketed both.

That night, the city lights bled through his curtains in streaks of orange and blue. Ethan sat on his bed, the coin resting upright on the table before him. He had tried to make it fall, but it refused — balanced impossibly, like it had roots.

He felt a pressure in the air, like something watching.This may contain: a hand is spinning a coin in the air

He whispered, “Why me?”

The shadows shifted.

And for the first time, the coin moved on its own — a slow, trembling roll — before stopping, perfectly upright again.

He felt it then — not a sound, not a voice, but a thought pressing against his skull.

Because you asked it to decide.

The next morning, his neighbor’s cat was waiting by his door, eyes fixed on him, tail twitching. It followed him down the hall, meowing like it knew something he didn’t.

When he reached the street, he saw the world differently. The sky seemed sharper, the edges of things too defined. Every passerby looked both familiar and strange.

He started noticing patterns — people crossing the street in mirrored rhythms, cars halting in perfect synchrony, raindrops falling in identical intervals.

It was as if the world had become a coin itself — balanced precariously between two outcomes.

He walked for hours, his fingers tight around the quarter in his pocket. When he finally stopped, he found himself at the old bridge again.

The same spot where he’d flipped it first.

The water below was black, swallowing reflections whole.

He took out the coin. “If I throw you away,” he said softly, “will you follow me?”

The wind didn’t answer, but the coin shimmered faintly, as if laughing.

He threw it. Hard.

It hit the surface of the river — and didn’t sink.

It stayed.

Balanced.

Floating on its edge.

That was the night the dreams began.

He’d wake in darkness to see versions of himself standing at the foot of his bed — one in a suit, one barefoot, one older, one younger — all silent, all watching.

Sometimes they’d whisper in unison.
You made us when you chose not to choose.Story Pin image

He’d wake gasping, only to find the coin back on his nightstand, perfectly balanced, glinting faintly in the dim light.

He stopped sleeping.

He stopped deciding.

Even eating became a gamble — every bite feeling like it would alter the world’s tilt. He started writing lists on his wall — “Left = danger?” “Right = reward?” “Flip = fate?” — but none of them made sense.

He was unraveling.

And the coin was winning.

One morning, he woke to find a note slipped under his door. No envelope, no name. Just handwriting he didn’t recognize:

“There’s another side to every edge.”

He turned it over.
Blank.

He went to the park, hoping for air, for logic — but the city didn’t feel like a city anymore. It felt like a reflection — a version of itself seen through a warped mirror.

People walked in loops. A man on a bench read the same page of his newspaper over and over. A bus passed twice, same number, same passengers.

Ethan’s heart raced. The coin was still in his pocket, heavy, vibrating faintly like it had a pulse.

He took it out. “What do you want?”

It landed on his palm, spinning once — and stopped, edge-down, balanced even against the tremor of his hand.

A sound rose around him — faint, metallic, like thousands of coins spinning at once.

And then, in a blink, the park emptied.

Every person vanished.

The city went silent.

Only Ethan remained.

And his reflection — across the grass, standing perfectly still, holding another coin.

They stared at each other.

The other Ethan smiled — not kindly. “You made me.”

Ethan shook his head. “No.”

“You did.” The voice was calm, even gentle. “Every time you refused to choose, I did it for you. You wanted certainty. Now you have it.”

“I never—”

The other Ethan flipped his coin. It spun midair, catching the light — and landed on its edge.

Both of them froze.

The wind stirred, bending trees in half, making the world hum.

Then the other Ethan said, “Only one of us gets to keep it.”This may contain: a bag full of coins sitting on top of a wooden table

Ethan felt the ground tremble beneath him. He reached into his pocket — his own coin was gone.

He looked up. The reflection was gone too.

Only the coin remained, standing in the center of the path, balanced perfectly.

That night, he didn’t go home. He wandered through the empty streets, feeling the city pulse like a living thing.

Every lamp flickered in rhythm. Every reflection watched him.

He stopped at a diner that should’ve been closed but wasn’t. The waitress greeted him without looking up.

“Coffee?”

He nodded.

When she set it down, he noticed her eyes. Silver. Mirrorlike.

She smiled faintly. “You’ve been flipping it too much.”

He stared. “You know about it?”

She nodded, wiping a glass that didn’t need cleaning. “The Edge chooses balance. Not luck. Not fate. Balance. Too right, too wrong — same thing.”

He frowned. “How do I stop it?”

“You don’t,” she said simply. “You either let it fall, or you become it.”

Before he could reply, she was gone. The diner empty again. Only his reflection remained in the window — smiling when he wasn’t.

Days blurred.

He stopped going to work. Stopped answering calls. The world outside kept flickering between versions — too bright, too dark, too quiet.

Every sound echoed twice. Every thought came back to him altered.

He tried throwing the coin away again. It returned. He tried breaking it. It reformed. He tried ignoring it. It whispered.

Until one night, when the city went silent again, and he realized he could hear it breathing.

Not the coin — the world.

Slow, steady, balanced.

He stood on his balcony, the skyline a forest of frozen light. He took the coin out, balanced it on the railing.

“If you fall,” he said softly, “I’ll stop.”

“If you stay,” he added, “I’ll understand.”

He flicked it.

It spun. The light caught every turn.

And it landed — perfectly — on its edge.

He laughed. A hollow, broken sound that turned into a sob.

Somewhere, a voice — maybe his own — whispered:
Maybe it’s not the coin that’s cursed. Maybe it’s you.

By morning, the city had reset again — alive, bustling, unaware. People moved like nothing had changed.

But Ethan wasn’t there.

In his apartment, on the table by the window, sat the coin — balanced as ever — next to a note:

“Every edge cuts both ways.”

The wind blew, rattling the curtains, and for the first time, the coin wavered. It trembled, slow and uncertain — and then, almost mercifully, it fell.

Heads.

The world sighed.

And somewhere, far from the city, a man who looked just like Ethan opened his eyes — in a quiet room, sunlight spilling across a table.

He smiled faintly, unaware of the faint line of silver that shimmered across his wrist.

Outside, a child flipped a coin, laughing when it landed on its edge.

The wind caught it, spinning it again, as if the universe couldn’t decide.

This may contain: a pile of coins sitting on top of a table next to another stack of gold coins

Want to read a bit more? Find some more of my writings here-

Chia Seeds: The Tiny Powerhouse of Nutrition That Transforms Your Health

Book Review: As Good As Dead by Holly Jackson

David Berkowitz: The “Son of Sam” Who Terrorized New York

I hope you liked the content.

To share your views, you can simply send me an email.

Thank you for being keen readers to a small-time writer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Blogs