The rain poured down in sheets, hammering against the grimy windows of Detective Arthur Hale’s office. It was late—far too late for anyone to be working—but Arthur didn’t care. He sat hunched over his desk, eyes bloodshot, staring at the case files scattered before him. It had been months since the first murder, but they were no closer to finding the killer. Each crime scene, meticulously cleaned of fingerprints, hair, or DNA, left no trace of the perpetrator—nothing except a small, unassuming puzzle piece.
The media had dubbed it the “Puzzle Killer,” and the city was gripped with fear. Five victims so far. Each body was found in a different part of the city, killed in a manner so clinical, so precise, that it bordered on art. And the puzzle pieces—the only thing that connected the victims—were maddening. Each one was different, from an ornate wooden puzzle. But no one could make sense of what it meant. Arthur had tried every angle. He’d stared at those puzzle pieces until they felt burned into his mind, trying to force them to reveal their secrets. But nothing made sense.
Until the day the first piece arrived at his door.
It was a nondescript brown envelope with no return address, simply marked “For Detective Arthur Hale.” Inside, a single puzzle piece—almost identical to the ones found at the crime scenes. The moment he saw it, his pulse quickened. Was this a taunt? A message from the killer? How had they gotten so close?
Arthur examined the piece carefully. There was nothing unique about it, at least not at first glance. But he knew this was no ordinary puzzle. He sensed a game was being played, and he was right in the middle of it.
Weeks passed. Then, another piece arrived. And another. Each in the same plain brown envelope, and each piece slightly different. They were coming faster now—sometimes two or three in a week. Arthur had started assembling them on the wall in his office, the image slowly taking shape, though he couldn’t yet tell what it was. The pieces were haunting him. He couldn’t sleep, couldn’t eat. His obsession with the case grew, taking over his every waking thought.
The more pieces he collected, the more he felt like the answer was just within his grasp. Every night, he would sit in his darkened office, staring at the incomplete puzzle on the wall, tracing the shapes with his eyes, feeling an inexplicable dread coiling in his chest. What was it? What was he missing?
The murders had stopped, as if the killer was waiting for him to finish the puzzle. Arthur felt like he was on a countdown, but to what, he didn’t know. The image began to take form, though it was still distorted—lines and shadows that didn’t yet make sense. His colleagues had started to worry about him. They said he looked gaunt, haggard. But Arthur brushed them off. He couldn’t stop now.
Then, one evening, he received the final piece.
It arrived in a box this time, the weight of it unsettling in his hand. He opened it carefully, knowing this was it—the moment of truth. Inside, nestled in tissue paper, was the last puzzle piece. He didn’t know why, but his hands trembled as he walked to the wall and placed the final piece into its slot.
And then, he saw it.
The image that stared back at him was his own face—his reflection, unmistakable in the puzzle’s grainy detail. His breath hitched in his throat, and a cold sweat broke out across his skin. He stumbled back, his mind reeling. How was this possible? Was this some kind of sick joke? Was someone trying to frame him?
But deep down, Arthur knew the truth. He felt it creeping into his bones, wrapping around his mind like a vice. His face wasn’t just there as the next victim—it was there because he was the killer.
The revelation hit him like a tidal wave, crashing over him with unbearable weight. Memories began flooding back, memories he had buried deep, memories that now clawed their way to the surface. The dark alleyways, the feel of the knife in his hand, the cold detachment as he watched the life drain from his victims’ eyes. It had been him all along. The Puzzle Killer wasn’t some faceless monster lurking in the shadows—it was Arthur Hale.
But how? How had he not known?
Dissociative amnesia. The term whispered in the back of his mind, a diagnosis he had once read about but never believed could apply to him. Arthur had been living two lives—one as the detective hunting the killer, and one as the killer himself, switching between personas without realizing it. The puzzle pieces were his subconscious trying to communicate, leaving clues in plain sight.
He sank into his chair, the weight of the truth crushing him. His hands, now steady, rested on the desk as the pieces fell into place—not just the puzzle, but the fragmented pieces of his mind. It all made sense now—the strange blackouts, the missing hours, the feeling of déjà vu at every crime scene.
He had been chasing himself.
Arthur’s mind raced, but there was nowhere to run from this truth. He was trapped, caught in a web of his own making. And now, he understood the final step. The puzzle was complete, and so was his role in the game.
There was only one thing left to do.
Arthur stood, feeling the weight of inevitability pressing down on him. He opened his desk drawer and pulled out the revolver he had carried for years. His reflection in the puzzle seemed to watch him, its expression cold, emotionless.
The final victim.
In the distance, he heard the faint sound of sirens. Someone was coming. Perhaps they had figured it out, or perhaps it was just routine. But it didn’t matter now. The game was over.
Arthur raised the gun to his temple, his finger trembling on the trigger. The puzzle was complete.
And then—click.
He squeezed, but nothing. The gun was empty. The realization dawned on him with a sickening jolt.
The game wasn’t over. Not yet.
Suddenly, the door burst open, and his partner, Detective Julia Marks, rushed in, gun drawn. Her eyes widened when she saw Arthur standing there, the gun to his head, the puzzle on the wall.
“What the hell are you doing, Arthur?” she demanded, voice shaking.
But Arthur didn’t answer. He couldn’t. His eyes were locked on the puzzle, the image of his own face slowly warping, shifting before his very eyes. The puzzle pieces were moving, rearranging themselves, forming something new.
Julia’s voice grew distant as Arthur stared, mesmerized, at the shifting puzzle. His own face disappeared, replaced by something far more sinister—something ancient, malevolent. A face that was not his, but one that had been controlling him all along.
He wasn’t the killer.
He was merely a pawn.
The real puppeteer had been pulling the strings all this time, and now, it was revealing itself.
The pieces clicked into place, forming an image of eyes—cold, soulless eyes staring directly at Arthur from the puzzle.
And then, everything went dark.
When Arthur woke, he was no longer in his office. He was somewhere else entirely—somewhere cold, damp, and suffocating. The walls were covered in the same puzzle pieces, all of them blank, stretching endlessly in every direction. There was no escape.
He was part of the puzzle now.
The final twist: Arthur had never been chasing the killer. He had been chasing his own mind, a fragmented reality created by something far more terrifying than dissociative amnesia—a force that had been manipulating him from the very beginning, a force that now had him trapped in a nightmare of his own making, forever unsolvable.
The real puzzle was never meant to be solved.
Want to read a bit more? Find some more of my writings here-
Book Review: The Predator by Runyx – A Dark Verse Masterpiece
The Empty Seat: A Terror Attack Poem of Unspoken Farewells
Perfect Home Office Setup for Remote Work Success
I hope you liked the content.
To share your views, you can simply send me an email.
Thank you for being keen readers to a small-time writer.
